BLACK FRIDAY · ONLINE ONLY · 20% OFF STOREWIDE*Ends 30 Nov. *Excludes sale items, special orders, lube, condoms, dolls & torsos, enhancement products & vouchers. While stock lasts – no rain checks or back orders.
Buying Guides

Best Butt Plugs for Beginners in Australia (2026): 6 Picks from $12.95

The best butt plugs and anal toys for beginners we stock in Australia, from a $12.95 silicone plug to training sets and remote plugs, plus the safety basics.

By Sexy Boutique Team 4 min read
Anal Plug Training Set 4 Clear

Curious about anal play but not sure where to start? The right first butt plug is small, smooth and has a wide, flared base. Here are the best butt plugs and anal toys for beginners we stock in Australia, from a $12.95 silicone plug to training sets and remote-control plugs, plus the safety basics.

Good to know: every order ships in plain, discreet packaging, and delivery is free across Australia on orders over $100. You can also pick up for free from our Carrum Downs store.

Quick picks

PickBest forPrice
Anal Plug Training Set 4Best overall: four sizes to build up slowly$39.95
HW Silicone Anal Plug SmallCheapest first plug$12.95
HW Plug Black SmallSmooth metal with a jewel base$27.95
HW Glass Anal Plug Blue HeartGlass: smooth and easy to clean$24.95
Ashella Vibes Jewel Remote Butt Plug SmallVibrating, with a remote$62.95
Ass-Sation Remote Vibrating P-Spot PlugProstate (P-spot) play$114.95

1. Best overall: Anal Plug Training Set 4

A training set is the easiest way to start, because you begin with the smallest plug and only move up when you are comfortable. The Anal Plug Training Set 4 ($39.95) gives you four graduated plugs, each with a flared base. It also comes in Pink and Purple, and there is a six-piece version, the HW Anal Plug Training Set 6 ($47.95).

2. Best budget first plug: HW Silicone Anal Plug Small

Just want to try it once? The HW Silicone Anal Plug Small ($12.95) is a small, soft silicone plug with a flared base. When you are ready, the Medium is $17.95.

3. Best jewelled plug: HW Plug Black Small

Metal plugs are smooth, feel weighty and can be warmed or cooled in water for extra sensation. The HW Plug Black Small ($27.95) has a crystal on the base, and there is a Medium for later.

4. Best glass plug: HW Glass Anal Plug Heart

Glass is non-porous, so it is very easy to keep clean. The HW Glass Anal Plug Blue Heart ($24.95) has a heart-shaped base; there is also a Pink Heart.

5. Best vibrating plug: Ashella Vibes Jewel Remote Butt Plug

Vibration helps you relax and adds a lot of sensation. The Ashella Vibes Jewel Remote Control Butt Plug Small ($62.95) comes with a remote, so a partner can take control. It also comes in Medium ($74.95) and Large ($82.95). Prefer an app? The Satisfyer Sweet Seal ($122.95) connects to the Satisfyer app.

6. Best for prostate play: Ass-Sation Remote Vibrating P-Spot Plug

For men and anyone with a prostate, a curved plug that reaches the P-spot can feel very different from a regular plug. The Ass-Sation Remote Vibrating P-Spot Plug ($114.95) has a flexible shaft, a stable base and a remote.

Anal play safety basics

  • Always use a flared base. Only use toys made for anal play, with a base that stops them going too far.
  • Use plenty of lube. The body does not make its own lubrication there. A thick water-based or silicone lube works best (avoid silicone lube on silicone toys). See our guide to the best lubes, which has an anal section.
  • Go slow and relax. Start small, breathe, and never force it. Stop if anything hurts.
  • Keep it clean. Wash toys before and after use, and don’t move a toy from anal to vaginal use without washing it. See our toy cleaning guide.

Butt plug FAQ

What size butt plug should a beginner start with?

Start with the smallest size you can find, ideally from a training set, and move up only when the smaller size feels easy.

Silicone, metal or glass?

Silicone is soft and flexible; metal and glass are firm, smooth and very easy to clean. All three are body-safe. Just remember: no silicone lube on silicone toys.

How long can I wear a butt plug?

Start with a few minutes and build up. Take it out if you feel any discomfort or numbness.

Is delivery discreet?

Yes. Every order ships in plain packaging with no product names on the outside.

Prices were correct at the time of writing and stock is limited on some models. Prefer to ask in person? Visit our Carrum Downs store, where our team is happy to help.

Shop all anal toys

Share this article

Keep reading

SHOPPING CART

close